People like to choose
Think about the last time you needed someone: a dentist, a mechanic, a builder. You probably looked around, read a little, and then got in touch with the one you'd decided felt right.
By the time you made contact, most of the deciding was done. That is how nearly everyone buys a service. The customer who rings you after reading about you is already half won.
Now turn it round. A stranger rings you about a job you mentioned to a website. You didn't choose them. You don't know who they are. That call starts from suspicion, not trust.
How sites that sell leads work
Sites such as Bark work like this: a customer describes what they need, and the site offers that request to businesses, who pay to get the customer's details and make contact. The same request is usually offered to several businesses, not one.
So when you pay for a lead, you aren't buying a customer. You are buying the chance to be one of several people contacting someone who has not chosen any of you.
It is worth being exact about what that means for your money:
- You pay whether or not you win the job.
- You are in a race: the first to ring often gets furthest, whatever their work is like.
- You are compared mostly on price, because the customer knows nothing else about you yet.
- The customer may be put off by several calls from strangers, and stop answering any of them.
Directories are different, but it is still someone else's shelf
Paid directories such as Checkatrade work another way: you pay to be listed, and customers who search there contact you. That is closer to how people like to buy, because the customer does the choosing.
But you are listed beside your competitors, the page you build up sits on the directory's site on its terms, and the fee carries on in a quiet month. It can earn its keep. It is rented space all the same.
When the customer finds you instead
A website of your own, set up to be found locally, puts you on the right side of all this. Someone searches, finds you, reads what you do, looks at your work and decides to get in touch.
That enquiry is yours alone. Nobody else was sent it. The person already has a reason to choose you, so the conversation is about the job, not about who you are.
And it is yours to keep: your own address, your own words, your own reviews, whatever happens to anyone else's site.
To be fair
Some businesses do well from lead sites and directories, especially when they are new and have no name yet. If you use one, judge it honestly: add up everything you paid over a few months and divide it by the jobs you actually won. That figure, not the price of one lead, is what it costs you.
Our view is simply that it is better to be found than to chase, and that the money spent chasing is usually better spent on being easy to find.
In short
- Customers who chose you are far easier to win than customers you chase
- A bought lead is a chance to compete, not a customer
- A directory listing is rented space beside your competitors
- Judge any lead source by what you paid for each job you actually won
Want to be easy to find?
Quolto designs, writes and looks after your website for you, from £7 a month, or £5.60 a month paid yearly, including VAT, with no contract on monthly billing.
Written by Quolto. We sell websites, so this is our view and you should weigh it as such. It describes how these services generally work and isn't a review of any one company: check their own sites for what they offer and charge today.